My Pitch for Die Hard 5
So they’re making Die Hard 5. There haven’t been a lot of story details leaked yet, but it sounds like it’ll widen the scope to a worldwide stage, as we see John McClane and his son wrapped up in some skirmish in Russia.
No. No, thanks. No. I am a big fan of the first Die Hard movie. It is both one of the best action movies and one of the best Christmas movies that has ever been put to film. It turned tv-actor Bruce Willis into movie-star Bruce Willis. The first Die Hard worked because John McClane was not a superhero, he was just a normal guy dealing with marital problems over the holidays, a normal guy who happened to get wrapped up in a terrorist threat at a high-tech tower. And when faced with that adversity, McClane became a hero, he walked barefoot over glass and yipi-kay-yayed all the motherfuckers to save his wife, who didn’t really want anything to do with him anyway.
But in each Die Hard sequel, we got farther and farther away from what made Die Hard good in the first place. As action set-pieces grew more over the top, CGI effects dominated the story, and John McClane was no longer an ordinary guy forced to be a hero, he was an action movie star and all of this was just more of the same for him. Coincidentally, each sequel was just more of the same for us too. Yawn.
To fix the Die Hard franchise, we don’t need to make the explosions bigger and put McClane in a foreign setting. To fix Die Hard, we have to make John McClane human again. No jumping off of skyscrapers. No hitching rides on the backs of fighter jets. John McClane needs to be a regular middle-aged dude.
So here is my pitch for Die Hard 5: John McClane is 56 years old. He’s got a gut. He doesn’t have a slick-shaved Patrick Stewart dome like in those posters for Die Hard 4—he’s balding. He’s only got a few hairs left, but he spends an hour every morning combing them over so it looks they’re more. He’s retired from the force. He never worked things out with his wife, but he still makes a drunken phone call every time he’s had too many beers in his lonely, one-bedroom, shit-hole apartment. “We can still make this work!” he yells onto her voicemail. His kids hate him, because he was never really there for them. He’s constantly telling everyone about that time he killed that German guy and saved that tower, but everyone’s already heard that story a million times.
The first ten minutes of this movie is John McClane spending Christmas 2012 alone.
Because Die Hard 5 is about John McClane turning his life around. For New Years Eve, he goes on a blind date. He doesn’t want to, but his loved ones make him because they’re sick of dealing with him—just like the audience is after the first fifteen minutes of the movie. And you know what, the date is going really well, despite his best socially-awkward efforts to self-destruct it, this woman really likes John. They have a lot in common, and barring any disaster, it’s easy to imagine a second date.
So he’s at this fancy restaurant in this brand new fancy hotel, and he has no idea how he’s going to afford this meal on his pension, but like I said, the date’s going really well. Of course, he doesn’t think it’s going well, he thinks he’s messing it up—in fact, he’s wishing for some kind of terrorist attack to happen just so he can show this woman what kind of action star he really is and—THE POWER GOES OUT.
Doors lock. Armed men surround all the tables. Everyone in the restaurant is taken hostage. Everyone in the hotel is locked in their rooms with the fancy new high-tech locks of this fancy new Los Angeles hotel. John gets his wish, there’s a terrorist attack. And it’s not Germans or Russians or hackers or whatever—The bad guys are militant Americans. Led by a Timothy McVeigh-like mad man who looks like he just stepped out of his bomb-shack, these are real bad guys. They aren’t silly action stereotypes, they’re something new, something we haven’t seen on film before. It’s raw, like if Heath Ledger’s Joker had no make-up and spoke in exaggerated Fox News talking points. They feel like a real threat. They ARE going to blow up this building, this brand new 5-star-hotel in downtown L.A., but first they’re going to get their faces all over TV. They’re gonna get their message across, they’re going to change this country, bring it back to its “original values.” But first they have to do something so that the government—THE WORLD—takes them seriously.
John McClane has to stop them. He has to stop this 9-11 level event from happening, but it’s even more complicated than 9-11, because these are Americans. Die Hard has always been about America, but to contemporize it, we need to show the current rift in American politics. John McClane has to save America—ALL SIDES OF AMERICA—and bring us all together.
But this isn’t the John McClane we remember. It’s been years, you guys. He’s scared. Whenever he tries to do something heroic, he starts shaking horribly. He has overwhelming panic attacks. The first time he fires a gun in Die Hard 5, he misses the guy he’s aiming at, and then he vomits uncontrollably. But over the course of the film, we get to see John McClane take baby steps on his journey to once again become the hero we know he can be. And not the crazy CGI action superstar—by the end of Die Hard 5 John McClane becomes the ordinary guy who, when backed into a corner, will do anything to protect his fellow man. And by the end of this terrible night, a night where the action doesn’t spread to an airport or Russia or Kevin Smith’s basement, but instead dramatically tears apart a five-star hotel floor by floor—while at the same time tearing apart John McClane’s insecurities and inadequacies—we get to see the forging—before our eyes—-of the modest hero we once knew. By the time the credits roll, a bruised, cut, bleeding, overweight, balding John McClane might look older, but he’s again the John McClane we remember. And wow, does his new love interest have one hell of a first date story.
Anyway, that’s my pitch. If this current Die Hard movie gets caught up in development hell or if you’re looking for something new for Die Hard 6, give me a call, Hollywood. Die Hard can be great again, let’s not all settle for another mediocre entry in the greatest action franchise in the world.